Question Period Note: VE DAY VIDEO
About
- Reference number:
- VAC-2019-QP-00019
- Date received:
- Dec 5, 2019
- Organization:
- Veterans Affairs Canada
- Name of Minister:
- MacAulay, Lawrence (Hon.)
- Title of Minister:
- Minister of Veterans Affairs
Suggested Response:
• The commemoration of all those who served is very important and needs to be carried out with the greatest sensitivity and respect.
• The video, which was posted to Veterans Affairs Canada’s social media platforms, was unacceptable and was removed as soon as the mistake was noticed.
• The Department has put in place additional measures within the approval process to ensure a similar mistake does not happen in the future.
• We recognize and remember all those who so selflessly served our country including the more than a million Canadian men and women served in World War II.
Background:
BACKGROUND – VE DAY VIDEO
On 9 May 2019, there was a CBC media article from Peter Zimonjic titled “Veterans Affairs bungles VE-Day video by showing Nazis”. The article said that Veterans Affairs Canada quickly deleted an online video it posted, to celebrate the 74th anniversary of VE-Day - upon realizing it showed images of the German Wehrmacht, the unified Nazi forces in the Second World War.
On Twitter, the message said: "74 years ago, crowds celebrated Victory in Europe (V-E) Day across the Allied nations. Today, we remember the service and sacrifice of those who fought for peace and freedom during the Second World War." The war in Europe ended on May 8, 1945.
Veterans Affairs Minister Lawrence MacAulay appeared on screen to present the short video explaining that "more than a million Canadian men and women served in this bitter conflict."
The sound of MacAulay's voice describing the war effort is then played over images of the German troops ending on the line: "Lest we forget."
Walter Dorn, a professor of defence studies at the Canadian Forces College and at the Royal Military College told CBC News it's unclear if there are any Canadian troops in the footage.
"Some of the images show German uniforms," Dorn said. "What's most notable is the eagle just above a Nazi symbol worn just above the right brevet."
Dorn said that while the depiction of German troops may offend some, he says the video was clearly made in error. He notes that many Germans, who are now our allies, died senselessly as victims of the Nazi regime, as did Allied forces.
"Such a glaring error has to be corrected as soon as possible and so I am glad they took it off," he said.
A spokesperson from Veterans Affairs said the video, which was posted to the department's social media platforms, was "unacceptable" and was removed as soon as the mistake was noticed.
Immediately following, the spokesperson said, “Minister MacAulay asked his deputy minister to review the approval process to ensure a similar mistake does not happen in the future.”
The Department has taken action by adding additional measures to the approval process to ensure a similar mistake does not happen in the future.
Additional Information:
None